Which college is better?

You should go to whatever college best suits what you want your major to be. I mean, with that SAT you could easily get into a prestigious school. You could consider Jesuit schools like Georgetown or Creighton. It doesn't really matter what college your degree is from. What matters is that you get an education best suited to your career preference. If Baylor seems to have a better program for your major, then it would be best to go there. Just because Emory is a higher ranked college doesn't mean it's the best school for you.